Like many, I have been watching the hit Netflix show, “Nobody Wants This,” which, among other things, follows a fictional California rabbi and his fiancé throughout their complicated lives. The show centers around the obstacles they face when it comes to work, family and their relationship as an interfaith couple. They seem to find themselves once and again in uncomfortable social and religious circumstances. He struggles at work for various reasons. They both struggle with their parents and siblings. While there is a lot to like about the show, I find it ultimately problematic and often misguided. Here’s why (without spoilers) ….
- Most of the women in the show are cast as stereotypes. Bina, the rabbi’s mom, is a prototypical Jewish mother. She is depicted as irrational, short-tempered and very difficult. Her husband is beholden to her as are her children. The characters must cater to her once and again. She comes off as a caricature at best, making Jewish women seem somehow unhinged and unlikable. The rabbi’s fiancé is also a kind of stereotype: helpless, incapable and highly dependent. Neither women are layered and complex. Neither offer anything akin to an array of emotions and strengths. To me, such depictions are short-sighted and insulting.
- The Judaism presented in the show is lacking. In the rabbi’s house there seem to be no books or Judaica. Is Judaism something to hide or be ashamed of? The high holy day sermon is generic and cliched. Those rituals that we do see are presented as ironic and much less serious. I do not expect a romcom Netflix show to present a robust Judaism, but it all feels apologetic and, to me, comes up short in this regard.
- The show suggests that we cannot fully connect across faith or difference. These family groups bump up against each other in ways that are very real. While I agree that two families overcoming differences around faith or race or sexuality will never be simple, the show presents it as nearly impossible. The truth is that lots of families are doing exactly this; KI is home to families that are diverse in every way. I see them navigating those differences – both within and beyond – their family structure in ways that are thoughtful, gentle and loving. I would hate to think that differences are deal breakers somehow.
In the end, I understand that “Nobody Wants This” is a Hollywood production. I get it. Its goal is not accuracy. It is not a documentary. The rabbi’s life looks very, very different from my own, which involves engaging in all of the beautiful, challenging and deeply meaningful aspects of this work. All of that said, I have to wonder, here in the fall of 2026, given today’s climate, if we need another show that plays to easy misconceptions and creates even some space for further animosity.
